Image Upload


File size must be less than 2Mb

You must have online publishing permission or full ownership of this image

File types (jpg, png, gif)






  • Hero image

EDITORIAL: More work to do

Sitting through the Horsham hearing of the Federal Government’s critical minerals inquiry gave a great sense of governments putting the ‘cart before the horse’.

Shouldn’t both levels of government – federal and state – already have policies in place before approving major projects?

Shouldn’t they have consulted with local governments, communities, landowners directly affected and a wide range of independent consultants before giving projects the green light? 

Shouldn’t governments have commissioned the appropriate research and studies to ensure that due diligence on critical mineral projects doesn’t leave lasting negative effects?



Article continues below


Evidence given at the Horsham hearing of the Standing Committee on Primary Industries’ Inquiry into factors shaping social licence and economic development outcomes in critical minerals projects across Australia suggests much more work needs to be done at a government level.

The governments’ lack of policy, plans and proper practices – or unwillingness to make them public – has left a great unknown and scepticism among many in our region.

While the two Wimmera mining proponents were not present at the Horsham hearing and did not make submissions, from reading the list of submitters to the inquiry, many mining companies and groups such as the Mineral Councils of Australia did contribute, so I’m sure other inquiry hearings showed a more balanced perspective to critical mineral mining.

But I can’t help but think the three MPs on the committee would have walked away from Horsham thinking there are far greater challenges to overcome in this region before mining will be fully embraced, and what role have governments played in this?

Among the inquiry’s terms of reference was to look at the effectiveness of engagement practices with local communities, traditional owners, and other stakeholders; how critical minerals projects contribute strategically to regional and national economic development; and opportunities to strengthen workforce participation, skills development, and employment pathways.

The other terms examined the role of state, territory, and local governments in supporting socially and economically sustainable development, and options for improved co-ordination between jurisdictions and the Commonwealth.

Much of these responsibilities lie with the government – their laws, practices, procedures and governance.

Evidence from Horsham and Yarrriambiack council representatives did not paint either level of government in a good light – with a clear lack of consultation, if not deliberate ignorance, on many fronts.

In such a rush to take advantage of the critical minerals resource, you can’t help but feel much of this process is rushed – governments are clearly not consulting with councils or communities because they do not want to be held up in their mission to make money off mining.

While regional development advocates can see the potential boost in terms of population growth and diversifying the local economy, even they presented at the hearing a long list of challenges that need to be overcome in order for the best possible outcomes.

Governments and proponents will never get 100 per cent of the community on board with the proposed projects, but developing stronger relationships with local governments would be good start, and who knows, may even be helpful.

Yes, the State Government allocated $1.3-million earlier this year to identify roads that needed investment; and support a study into accommodation review and enabling infrastructure required in the region ahead of the projects.

But as Yarriambiack chief executive Tammy Smith outlined, her council had so far made 11 applications for funding for enabling infrastructure –  and spent more than $250,000 in doing so –  without any success.

Not to mention the hundreds of thousands of dollars that councils are spending on submissions to Environmental Effect Statements and other government approvals.

This is all ratepayers’ money –  and it’s diverting council funding away from other services in our communities.

The extra burden on council workloads and costs may well be worth it if they could see upfront investment happening, and the region being properly prepared for this influx of mining and renewable projects.

Horsham Rural City Council chief executive Gail Gatt said the council was not confident current economic modelling fully captured the true costs and benefits of mining for communities, the state or the nation.

“We feel that mining proposals should include a social benefit cost analysis prior to any EES process, and that hasn’t happened in the case of recent mining approvals that have taken place in our region,” she told the hearing.

“Any assessment needs to consider loss of productive farmland and soil, impacts on farming communities and regional stability, food security, environmental health, long-term and intergenerational impacts, and private benefit compared with public costs.”

Mining is not new for this country, or indeed around the world, so why is it so hard for governments to have robust policy and procedures in place before it gets to the point of approvals? 

Preparation is key in this process to change and diversify the region, and the buck stops and starts with the governments.

The entire October 28, 2026 edition of The Weekly Advertiser is available online. READ IT HERE!

The entire October 29, 2026 edition of AgLife is available online. READ IT HERE!